Free modal-overuse detection tool
List the modals in your product and get each one scored against whether a modal is really the right pattern, with a lighter alternative suggested for the ones that aren't.
Your entries remain in this browser session and are not sent to MVPHub.
Your inputs
Enter one modal per line as Modal purpose | blocks destructive action (yes/no) | frequency seen per session.
Your calculated result
Planning score
A modal is well-justified when it blocks a genuinely destructive or high-stakes action; modals used for routine forms, previews, or frequent prompts score poorly since a modal interrupts flow more than the task warrants.
A modal appearing many times per session compounds its disruption cost — even a mildly unnecessary modal becomes a real problem at high frequency.
Non-destructive, frequent modals are matched to a lighter pattern — inline editing, a slide-over panel, a toast, or an inline banner — appropriate to their purpose.
No — a modal is the right pattern for genuinely destructive or irreversible actions (like deleting an account) where you want to force a deliberate pause. The problem is using it for routine, frequent, or non-destructive tasks.
Inline editing or a slide-over panel usually works better — it keeps context visible and doesn't force a jarring focus trap for a routine, frequent task.
A one-time onboarding modal seen once per user is generally fine; the problem is a modal-based tour that reappears across many sessions.
ModalGuard audits your existing set of modals for overuse in general; ConfirmUX specifically designs the confirmation pattern for destructive or high-stakes actions, modal or not.
| Capability | MVPHub | Defaulting to a modal for every new feature | A generic UI pattern library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scores your actual modals for justification | ✓ | × | × |
| Weighs disruption by real frequency | ✓ | × | × |
| Suggests a specific lighter alternative | ✓ | × | — |
| Instant, no design engagement required | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
MVPHub scores your product's actual modals against destructiveness and frequency. Defaulting to modals for everything, or picking from a generic pattern library, doesn't account for your specific interruption cost.
