Enter performance figures for both carriers
Add on-time delivery rate, damage rate, cost index, and claims count for Carrier A and Carrier B.
CARRIER COMPARISON SCORE
CarrierScore AI
Enter on-time delivery rate, damage rate, cost index, and claims count for two carriers to get a weighted composite score, a ranked winner, and the score gap.
- Uses your inputs in a transparent calculation
- Instant result with practical next steps
- No signup required
Planning guidance only. Validate important decisions with customer evidence and your delivery team.
YOUR INPUTS
Build your result
Complete every field. The result updates only when you choose Calculate.
How it works
We calculate a weighted composite score
Each carrier gets a 0-100 score from on-time rate (40%), damage rate (25%, inverted), cost index (20%, inverted), and claims count (15%, inverted), each normalized against a reasonable cap.
Get a ranked winner and the score gap
The result names the stronger carrier, shows both composite scores, and reports the point gap between them.
Continue learning: MVP development checklist · Which MVP metrics matter?
Frequently asked questions
Does CarrierScore AI pull live carrier performance data?
No. CarrierScore AI computes results only from the numbers you enter — it does not connect to live carrier scorecards, telematics, or freight networks. It is a comparison calculator, not a live monitoring system.
Where do these carrier figures come from?
Use your own shipment records, carrier-provided scorecards, or your TMS reports. Even approximate figures from a recent period give a useful comparison.
Why is damage rate inverted in the score?
A lower damage rate is better, so the score rewards carriers with fewer damage incidents by inverting the percentage against a normalization cap before weighting.
Can I compare more than 2 carriers?
This tool compares exactly two carriers side by side. To compare more, run the tool multiple times pairing different carriers, or track the leading carrier against each challenger separately.
What does the score gap actually mean?
The gap is the difference in composite points between the winning and losing carrier. A small gap means the carriers are closely matched; a large gap suggests a materially stronger performer.
Is the winning carrier guaranteed to be the right choice?
No. The score reflects only the four metrics entered. Contract terms, capacity, lane coverage, and relationship factors should also inform your carrier decision.
How We Compare
| Feature | MVPHub | project44 | FourKites |
|---|---|---|---|
| Instant two-carrier score comparison | Included | Limited | Limited |
| Live multi-carrier network visibility | Not included | Included | Included |
| No signup required to try the calculation | Included | Not included | Not included |
| Transparent, editable weighting formula | Included | Limited | Limited |
project44 and FourKites provide live multi-carrier visibility networks across large freight operations. MVPHub gives a fast, transparent two-carrier score comparison from figures you enter, with no setup.
Related tools
Embed this tool
Add this tool to your site with the canonical iframe below. It remains hosted and maintained by MVPHub.